*In ( ) is where I had the players rated during the draft process.
Quarterback
1st Team
Teddy Bridgewater, Vikings (Louisville, #3 QB - #17 OVR – First Round)
2nd Team
Derek Carr, Raiders (Fresno State, #4 QB - #40 OVR - Second Round)
1st Team
Teddy Bridgewater, Vikings (Louisville, #3 QB - #17 OVR – First Round)
2nd Team
Derek Carr, Raiders (Fresno State, #4 QB - #40 OVR - Second Round)
Running Back
1st Team
Jeremy Hill, Bengals (LSU, #2 RB - #44 OVR – Second Round)
Tre Mason, Rams (Auburn, #3 RB - #59 OVR - Second Round)
2nd Team
Andre Williams, Giants (Boston College, #5 RB - #73 OVR – Third Round)
Isaiah Crowell, Browns (Alabama State, #19 RB - #178 OVR – Sixth Round)
1st Team
Jeremy Hill, Bengals (LSU, #2 RB - #44 OVR – Second Round)
Tre Mason, Rams (Auburn, #3 RB - #59 OVR - Second Round)
2nd Team
Andre Williams, Giants (Boston College, #5 RB - #73 OVR – Third Round)
Isaiah Crowell, Browns (Alabama State, #19 RB - #178 OVR – Sixth Round)
Wide Receiver
1st Team
Odell Beckham Jr., Giants (LSU, #4 WR - #20 OVR – First Round)
Kelvin Benjamin, Panthers (Florida State, #7 WR – #39 OVR – Second Round)
Mike Evans, Bucs (Texas A&M, #2 WR - #8 OVR – First Round)
2nd Team
Sammy Watkins, Bills (Clemson, #1 WR - #5 OVR – First Round)
Jordan Matthews, Eagles (Vanderbilt, #6 WR - #37 OVR – Second Round)
John Brown, Arizona (Pittsburg State, #21 WR – #150 OVR – Fifth Round)
1st Team
Odell Beckham Jr., Giants (LSU, #4 WR - #20 OVR – First Round)
Kelvin Benjamin, Panthers (Florida State, #7 WR – #39 OVR – Second Round)
Mike Evans, Bucs (Texas A&M, #2 WR - #8 OVR – First Round)
2nd Team
Sammy Watkins, Bills (Clemson, #1 WR - #5 OVR – First Round)
Jordan Matthews, Eagles (Vanderbilt, #6 WR - #37 OVR – Second Round)
John Brown, Arizona (Pittsburg State, #21 WR – #150 OVR – Fifth Round)
Tight End
1st Team
Jace Amaro, Jets (Texas Tech, #2 TE - #26 OVR – First Round)
2nd Team
Crockett Gilmore, Ravens (Colorado State, #12 TE - #166 OVR – Fifth Round)
1st Team
Jace Amaro, Jets (Texas Tech, #2 TE - #26 OVR – First Round)
2nd Team
Crockett Gilmore, Ravens (Colorado State, #12 TE - #166 OVR – Fifth Round)
Offensive Tackle
1st Team
Jake Matthews, Falcons (Texas A&M, #2 OT - #3 OVR – First Round)
Justin Britt, Seahawks (Missouri, #14 OT - #139 OVR - Fifth Round)
2nd Team
Taylor Lewan, Titans (Michigan, #3 OT - #6 OVR – First Round)
Ja’Wuan James, Dolphins (Tennessee, #7 OT - #45 OVR – Second Round)
1st Team
Jake Matthews, Falcons (Texas A&M, #2 OT - #3 OVR – First Round)
Justin Britt, Seahawks (Missouri, #14 OT - #139 OVR - Fifth Round)
2nd Team
Taylor Lewan, Titans (Michigan, #3 OT - #6 OVR – First Round)
Ja’Wuan James, Dolphins (Tennessee, #7 OT - #45 OVR – Second Round)
Center
1st Team
Bryan Stork, Patriots (Florida State, #4 C - #159 OVR – Fifth Round)
2nd Team
Corey Linsley, Packers (Ohio State, #8 C - #270 OVR – Undrafted)
1st Team
Bryan Stork, Patriots (Florida State, #4 C - #159 OVR – Fifth Round)
2nd Team
Corey Linsley, Packers (Ohio State, #8 C - #270 OVR – Undrafted)
Offensive Guard
1st Team
Joel Bitonio, Browns (Nevada, #6 OT, #38 OVR – Second Round)
Zack Martin, Cowboys (Notre Dame, #1 OG - #22 OVR - First Round)
2nd Team
Gabe Jackson, Raiders (Mississippi State, #4 OG - #36 OVR – Second Round)
Brandon Linder, Jaguars (Miami, #12 OG - #193 OVR – Sixth Round)
1st Team
Joel Bitonio, Browns (Nevada, #6 OT, #38 OVR – Second Round)
Zack Martin, Cowboys (Notre Dame, #1 OG - #22 OVR - First Round)
2nd Team
Gabe Jackson, Raiders (Mississippi State, #4 OG - #36 OVR – Second Round)
Brandon Linder, Jaguars (Miami, #12 OG - #193 OVR – Sixth Round)
Defensive End
1st Team
Timmy Jernigan, Ravens (Florida State, #3 DT - #23 OVR – First Round)
Kerry Wynn, Giants (Richmond, #23 DE - #263 OVR - Undrafted)
2nd Team
Stephon Tuitt, Steelers (Notre Dame, #4 DT - #46 OVR – Second Round)
Kony Ealy, Panthers (Missouri, #2 DE - #54 OVR – Second Round)
1st Team
Timmy Jernigan, Ravens (Florida State, #3 DT - #23 OVR – First Round)
Kerry Wynn, Giants (Richmond, #23 DE - #263 OVR - Undrafted)
2nd Team
Stephon Tuitt, Steelers (Notre Dame, #4 DT - #46 OVR – Second Round)
Kony Ealy, Panthers (Missouri, #2 DE - #54 OVR – Second Round)
Defensive Tackle
1st Team
Aaron Donald, Rams (Pittsburgh, #1 DT - #7 OVR – First Round)
Justin Ellis, Raiders (Louisiana Tech, #15 DT - #182 OVR – Sixth Round)
2nd Team
Zach Kerr, Colts (Delaware, #NA - #NA OVR – Undrafted)
Ego Ferguson, Bears (LSU, #21 DT - #271 OVR – Undrafted)
1st Team
Aaron Donald, Rams (Pittsburgh, #1 DT - #7 OVR – First Round)
Justin Ellis, Raiders (Louisiana Tech, #15 DT - #182 OVR – Sixth Round)
2nd Team
Zach Kerr, Colts (Delaware, #NA - #NA OVR – Undrafted)
Ego Ferguson, Bears (LSU, #21 DT - #271 OVR – Undrafted)
Linebacker
1st Team
Anthony Barr, Vikings (UCLA, #2 OLB - #9 OVR – First Round)
Khalil Mack, Raiders (Buffalo, #1 OLB - #4 OVR - First Round)
2nd Team
Preston Brown, Bills (Louisville, #8 ILB - #184 OVR – Sixth Round)
Christian Kirksey, Browns (Iowa, #12 OLB - #183 OVR – Sixth Round)
1st Team
Anthony Barr, Vikings (UCLA, #2 OLB - #9 OVR – First Round)
Khalil Mack, Raiders (Buffalo, #1 OLB - #4 OVR - First Round)
2nd Team
Preston Brown, Bills (Louisville, #8 ILB - #184 OVR – Sixth Round)
Christian Kirksey, Browns (Iowa, #12 OLB - #183 OVR – Sixth Round)
Linebacker
1st Team
Chris Borland, 49ers (Wisconsin, #2 ILB - #48 OVR – Second Round)
CJ Mosley, Ravens (Alabama, #1 ILB - #14 ILB - First Round)
2nd Team
Jonathan Newsome, Colts (Ball State, #20 OLB - #265 OVR – Undrafted)
Telvin Smith, Jaguars *OLB (Florida State, #10 OLB - #149 OVR – Fifth Round)
1st Team
Chris Borland, 49ers (Wisconsin, #2 ILB - #48 OVR – Second Round)
CJ Mosley, Ravens (Alabama, #1 ILB - #14 ILB - First Round)
2nd Team
Jonathan Newsome, Colts (Ball State, #20 OLB - #265 OVR – Undrafted)
Telvin Smith, Jaguars *OLB (Florida State, #10 OLB - #149 OVR – Fifth Round)
Safety
1st Team
HaHa Clinton-Dix, Packers (Alabama, #1 FS - #15 OVR – First Round)
Deone Bucannon, Cardinals (Washington State, #2 SS - #28 OVR – First Round)
2nd Team
Tre Boston, Panthers (North Carolina, #7 FS - #111 OVR – Fourth Round)
Calvin Pryor, Jets (Louisville, #2 FS - #24 OVR – First Round)
1st Team
HaHa Clinton-Dix, Packers (Alabama, #1 FS - #15 OVR – First Round)
Deone Bucannon, Cardinals (Washington State, #2 SS - #28 OVR – First Round)
2nd Team
Tre Boston, Panthers (North Carolina, #7 FS - #111 OVR – Fourth Round)
Calvin Pryor, Jets (Louisville, #2 FS - #24 OVR – First Round)
Cornerback
1st Team
Kyle Fuller, Bears (Virginia Tech, #5 CB - #35 OVR – Second Round)
Bashaud Breeland, Redskins (Clemson, #11 CB - #99 OVR – Third Round)
2nd Team
Bene Benwikere, Panthers (San Jose State, #27 CB - #272 OVR – Undrafted)
EJ Gaines, Rams (Missouri, #19 CB - #240 OVR – Seventh Round)
1st Team
Kyle Fuller, Bears (Virginia Tech, #5 CB - #35 OVR – Second Round)
Bashaud Breeland, Redskins (Clemson, #11 CB - #99 OVR – Third Round)
2nd Team
Bene Benwikere, Panthers (San Jose State, #27 CB - #272 OVR – Undrafted)
EJ Gaines, Rams (Missouri, #19 CB - #240 OVR – Seventh Round)
Kicker
1st Team
Cody Parkey, Eagles (Auburn, #NA K - #NA OVR - Undrafted)
2nd Team
Chandler Catanzaro, Cardinals (Clemson, #4 K - #NA OVR - Undrafted)
1st Team
Cody Parkey, Eagles (Auburn, #NA K - #NA OVR - Undrafted)
2nd Team
Chandler Catanzaro, Cardinals (Clemson, #4 K - #NA OVR - Undrafted)
Punter
1st Team
Pat O'Donnell, Bears (Miami, #3 P - #NA OVR - Undrafted)
2nd Team
No other rookie punter
1st Team
Pat O'Donnell, Bears (Miami, #3 P - #NA OVR - Undrafted)
2nd Team
No other rookie punter